Top Real Estate Agents in Old Lyme, Connecticut (2026)
Old Lyme, Connecticut's picturesque coastal charm and thriving artist community have made it one of the state's most desirable waterfront destinations. Our directory connects you with top-performing real estate professionals who collectively closed 239 transactions totaling $146 million in sales volume, with individual agents leading the market and William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty establishing itself as the area's dominant brokerage.
- 239
- Transactions
- $146M
- Sales volume
- 5
- Ranked agents
- William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty
- Most listed brokerage
2 rankings for Old Lyme
Each list is its own ranking by sales volume. The number starts again at 1, so a team ranked 1 is not compared with an individual ranked 1.
5 agents
Individuals by Volume
| Rank | Agent | Volume | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tammy Tinnerello William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty | $34.38M 45 transactions | |
| 2 | Joseph Malerba eXp Realty | $21.53M 59 transactions | |
| 3 | Jodi Strycharz Coldwell Banker Realty | $14.60M 12 transactions |
Small Teams by Volume
| Rank | Agent | Volume | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Nancy Mesham Team Coldwell Banker Realty | $50.78M 70 transactions | |
| 2 | The A Team of William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty | $24.21M 53 transactions |
How the Old Lyme list actually works
Old Lyme does not have a deep bench. Start with Tammy Tinnerello (William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty) and the other ranked producers, then read the disclosure on the house itself.
Questions about Old Lyme agents
Who are the top real estate agents in Old Lyme, Connecticut?
Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty is number 1 for individuals by volume in Old Lyme. The other 1 lists on this page rank teams separately, so each list starts again at 1.
How do I find a realtor in Old Lyme?
Search this page by name or brokerage, then compare sales volume and transaction count. Call, email, or open the website on the agent's card.
What should I check before hiring an agent in Old Lyme?
Read the seller's disclosure for the house itself. IonDocs flags the repairs, permits, and HOA costs that should change the price.
Have a house in Old Lyme?
The agent list is the start. The seller's packet is where the price changes.
Check a Old Lyme disclosureAgent in Old Lyme?
Review a disclosure in about a minute. Join other Connecticut agents on IonDocs.
Analyze Your First Property Free