Top Real Estate Agents in Middletown, New Jersey (2026)

Middletown, New Jersey's real estate market is thriving, with top agents collectively closing over 422 transactions and $303 million in sales volume. This dynamic Monmouth County community offers a blend of suburban comfort and convenient access to coastal living, making it an increasingly attractive destination for homebuyers seeking both quality schools and waterfront proximity.

422
Transactions
$303M
Sales volume
20
Ranked agents
RE/MAX First Class
Most listed brokerage

3 rankings for Middletown

Each list is its own ranking by sales volume. The number starts again at 1, so a team ranked 1 is not compared with an individual ranked 1.

20 agents

Individuals by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Nicole Kelly

Coldwell Banker Realty

$36.65M

32 transactions

2

Eric Bosniak

Coldwell Banker Realty

$34.56M

42 transactions

3

Kathy Froelich

Redfin

$33.13M

49 transactions

4

Kim Spector

Coldwell Banker Realty

$31.31M

38 transactions

5

Sharon Hayes

Coldwell Banker Realty

$17.37M

19 transactions

6

Fran Judas

Coldwell Banker Realty

$16.53M

22 transactions

7

Dennis Freshnock

RE/MAX First Class

$13.40M

22 transactions

8

Shira Perlstein

Coldwell Banker Realty

$13.14M

17 transactions

9

Leonard "Len" Dipaolo

Coldwell Banker Realty

$11.53M

6 transactions

10

Katie Kelliher

Coldwell Banker Realty

$10.84M

14 transactions

11

Amy Beltempo

RE/MAX First Class

$7.80M

8 transactions

12

Kristina Mager

RE/MAX First Class

$5.89M

10 transactions

13

Arlene Perrotti

RE/MAX First Class

$5.75M

9 transactions

14

Eva Acevedo

RE/MAX First Class

$4.53M

9 transactions

15

Charles O'Rourke

RE/MAX First Class

$4.20M

11 transactions

16

Steven Sellitti

RE/MAX First Class

$4.16M

7 transactions

17

Steven Lopes

RE/MAX First Class

$4.13M

6 transactions

18

Shara Moran

RE/MAX First Class

$4.11M

7 transactions

Small Teams by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Pilot Real Estate Group

RE/MAX First Class

$13.89M

39 transactions

Medium Teams by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Team Sirchio

RE/MAX First Class

$30.31M

55 transactions

How to use a Middletown list owned by one firm

Start with Nicole Kelly at Coldwell Banker Realty, then look at who else at RE/MAX First Class covers Middletown. The firm is the pattern. The house still has its own disclosure.

Questions about Middletown agents

Who are the top real estate agents in Middletown, New Jersey?

Nicole Kelly of Coldwell Banker Realty is number 1 for individuals by volume in Middletown. The other 2 lists on this page rank teams separately, so each list starts again at 1.

How do I find a realtor in Middletown?

Search this page by name or brokerage, then compare sales volume and transaction count. Call, email, or open the website on the agent's card.

What should I check before hiring an agent in Middletown?

Read the seller's disclosure for the house itself. IonDocs flags the repairs, permits, and HOA costs that should change the price.

Have a house in Middletown?

The agent list is the start. The seller's packet is where the price changes.

Check a Middletown disclosure

Agent in Middletown?

Review a disclosure in about a minute. Join other New Jersey agents on IonDocs.

Analyze Your First Property Free