Top Real Estate Agents in Bay Shore, New York (2026)

Bay Shore is a vibrant waterfront community on Long Island's South Shore, known for its scenic coastal charm and proximity to New York City. Our directory connects you with top-performing real estate professionals who have closed over 111 transactions totaling $86 million in sales volume, with individual agents leading the market and EXIT Realty All Pro emerging as the area's dominant brokerage.

111
Transactions
$86M
Sales volume
4
Ranked agents
EXIT Realty All Pro
Most listed brokerage

One ranking for Bay Shore

This list is ordered by sales volume. The rank is the place in this list.

4 agents

Individuals by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Ricardo Pena

The Agency (Long Island) Northshore NY

$34.32M

43 transactions

2

Lenny Simonetti

EXIT Realty All Pro

$20.33M

32 transactions

3

Meg Smith

Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

$19.16M

15 transactions

4

Larry Gardner

EXIT Realty All Pro

$12.15M

21 transactions

How the Bay Shore list actually works

Bay Shore does not have a deep bench. Start with Ricardo Pena (The Agency (Long Island) Northshore NY) and the other ranked producers, then read the disclosure on the house itself.

Questions about Bay Shore agents

Who are the top real estate agents in Bay Shore, New York?

Ricardo Pena of The Agency (Long Island) Northshore NY is number 1 for individuals by volume in Bay Shore.

How do I find a realtor in Bay Shore?

Search this page by name or brokerage, then compare sales volume and transaction count. Call, email, or open the website on the agent's card.

What should I check before hiring an agent in Bay Shore?

Read the seller's disclosure for the house itself. IonDocs flags the repairs, permits, and HOA costs that should change the price.

Have a house in Bay Shore?

The agent list is the start. The seller's packet is where the price changes.

Check a Bay Shore disclosure

Agent in Bay Shore?

Review a disclosure in about a minute. Join other New York agents on IonDocs.

Analyze Your First Property Free