Top Real Estate Agents in Shelter Island, New York (2026)

Discover Shelter Island's premier real estate agents specializing in this exclusive North Fork destination. With top agents commanding $71 million in combined sales volume and 32 transactions, our directory connects you with experienced professionals who understand the island's unique waterfront properties, historic estates, and tight-knit community. Whether you're seeking a bay-view home or investment property, find the right agent to navigate Shelter Island's competitive luxury market.

32
Transactions
$71M
Sales volume
4
Ranked agents
Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Most listed brokerage

One ranking for Shelter Island

This list is ordered by sales volume. The rank is the place in this list.

4 agents

Individuals by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Penelope Moore

Saunders & Associates

$29.00M

12 transactions

2

Gina Surerus

Corcoran

$19.61M

7 transactions

3

Tina Marika Kaasik

Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

$12.40M

7 transactions

4

Mackenzie Needham

Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty

$10.01M

6 transactions

How the Shelter Island list actually works

Shelter Island does not have a deep bench. Start with Penelope Moore (Saunders & Associates) and the other ranked producers, then read the disclosure on the house itself.

Questions about Shelter Island agents

Who are the top real estate agents in Shelter Island, New York?

Penelope Moore of Saunders & Associates is number 1 for individuals by volume in Shelter Island.

How do I find a realtor in Shelter Island?

Search this page by name or brokerage, then compare sales volume and transaction count. Call, email, or open the website on the agent's card.

What should I check before hiring an agent in Shelter Island?

Read the seller's disclosure for the house itself. IonDocs flags the repairs, permits, and HOA costs that should change the price.

Have a house in Shelter Island?

The agent list is the start. The seller's packet is where the price changes.

Check a Shelter Island disclosure

Agent in Shelter Island?

Review a disclosure in about a minute. Join other New York agents on IonDocs.

Analyze Your First Property Free