Top Real Estate Agents in Payson, Arizona (2026)

Payson is a charming mountain community nestled in Arizona's high country, known for its cool climate, natural beauty, and thriving retirement community. Our directory connects you with the region's top real estate professionals, including leading agents from ERA Young Realty & Investment, who have collectively closed 189 transactions totaling $96 million in sales volume and understand the unique appeal of this peaceful pine-forested destination.

189
Transactions
$96M
Sales volume
7
Ranked agents
ERA Young Realty & Investment
Most listed brokerage

One ranking for Payson

This list is ordered by sales volume. The rank is the place in this list.

7 agents

Individuals by Volume

RankAgentVolumeContact
1

Kristin Croak

ERA Young Realty & Investment

$24.67M

30 transactions

2

Rory Huff

ERA Young Realty & Investment

$20.22M

44 transactions

3

Suzy Tubbs

ERA Young Realty & Investment

$19.71M

30 transactions

4

Brenda Altfeltis

ERA Young Realty & Investment

$11.23M

19 transactions

5

Sherrie Vrankovic

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Advantage Realty

$8.51M

30 transactions

6

Jacqueline Thresher

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Advantage Realty

$7.89M

28 transactions

7

Anthony Calhoun

RE/MAX Elite

$4.04M

9 transactions

How the Payson list actually works

Payson does not have a deep bench. Start with Kristin Croak (ERA Young Realty & Investment) and the other ranked producers, then read the disclosure on the house itself.

Questions about Payson agents

Who are the top real estate agents in Payson, Arizona?

Kristin Croak of ERA Young Realty & Investment is number 1 for individuals by volume in Payson.

How do I find a realtor in Payson?

Search this page by name or brokerage, then compare sales volume and transaction count. Call, email, or open the website on the agent's card.

What should I check before hiring an agent in Payson?

Read the seller's disclosure for the house itself. IonDocs flags the repairs, permits, and HOA costs that should change the price.

Have a house in Payson?

The agent list is the start. The seller's packet is where the price changes.

Check a Payson disclosure

Agent in Payson?

Review a disclosure in about a minute. Join other Arizona agents on IonDocs.

Analyze Your First Property Free